A fundamental rule of nature is that nothing travels faster than the speed of light. Now, physicists working in Europe say they may have discovered a sub-atomic particle that breaks that speed limit. But that extraordinary claim is being greeted with a healthy dose of skepticism.
When highway engineers bored a six-mile long tunnel through the Gran Sasso mountain in Italy, physicists convinced them to dig them an underground laboratory there, while they were at it. That lab houses a target for subatomic particles that get shot through the Earth’s crust from a particle accelerator on the Swiss-French border, more than 450 miles away. It’s remarkable that these ghostly particles, called neutrinos, have no trouble traveling though solid rock.
“They’re very light, they’re very tiny, they interact very, very weakly, they’re constantly passing through us, they’re constantly passing through the Earth,” says James Gillies, a physicist at CERN, the lab that produces these neutrinos. “But because there are so many of them, their influence is quite large.”
CERN fires the neutrinos down to the lab in Italy so scientists there can watch as these neutrinos do the strange things that they do, such as changing from one type of neutrino to another. Now, the scientists say they’ve made an even more remarkable observation: Their latest results suggest that these neutrinos travel faster than the speed of light. Gillies says this violates one of the fundamental building blocks of modern physics.
“If real, it’s a very surprising result,” he says. “That’s a very big if.”
The team of 160 scientists, from 11 countries, made their case today at a seminar at CERN. To measure the neutrino’s speed, they need to know exactly when the particles leave the accelerator, when they arrive in Italy, and exactly what distance they traveled. And that’s tricky. For instance, collaboration spokesman Dario Autiero said they wanted to shut down traffic in the tunnel near the underground lab in order to make precise distance measurements.
“In the end we negotiated so stop one lane in one of the two independent tunnels.”
And they were able to nail the distance from the Swiss accelerator to their detector to within a foot. They also spent many months getting clocks to synch up to within a few billionths of a second. In short, Autiero said they simply can’t find any errors that would explain their result.
“Therefore we present to you today this discrepancy, this anomaly,” Autiero said at the seminar.
The anomaly he’s referring to is that of an object traveling faster than the speed of light. That violates Einstein’s theory of relativity, so if it’s true, it would upset a great deal of modern physics. Even so, the reaction at the seminar was more than just polite.
Physicists in the audience praised the team for its painstaking work, then spent the next hour asking pointed questions about the experiment. They found no glaring, fatal flaw, but Jenny Thomas from the University College London, says that’s not to say anyone — including Autiero himself — believes that they really have dealt a serious blow to the theory of relativity.
“It’s always exiting to be forced to think out of the box,” Thomas says. “But in the end I’m not waking up at night worrying, ‘Oh my God, Oh my God, neutrinos go faster than the speed of light.’ “
In fact, Thomas is involved in a similar experiment in the United States involving an accelerator in Illinois and an underground lab in Minnesota. And they’re gearing up now to put the European claim to the test.