Looking For 'Oxygen,' Small Papers Erect Digital Paywalls
The Washington Post and the San Francisco Chronicle recently said they will start charging readers for online content, joining big papers like The New York Times and The Wall Street Journal. Some large papers have made it work because they offer a lot of unique content.
But the same holds true for tiny community newspapers, like the weekly Chinook Observer tucked in an isolated corner of Washington state.
Newspapers big and small have a similar goal: economic survival.
An Avid Reader
Steve Rogers is a commissioner for Pacific County along the coast of Washington state. The county is about the size of Rhode Island but only has 20,000 residents. In the parking lot of the McDonald's in the town of Long Beach, Rogers climbs into his truck to take advantage of the free Wi-Fi.
He pulls out his iPad to show all the news he reads online: "Seattle Times, P-I [Seattle Post-Intelligencer], Washington Post, New York Post, Christian Science Monitor...."
But his favorite news app is the Chinook Observer. It's a weekly newspaper with a print circulation of 5,500, published in Long Beach. Rogers reads everything in it — from a front-page story about plans for a marijuana grow operation all the way to job ads.
Rogers subscribes to the print version, so he gets the app for free. But he's thinking about going to a Web-only subscription. (A one-year print subscription costs $36; a Web-only subscription is $33.)
"I had a little bit of reluctance at first because we have the sense of the Internet being free," Rogers says. "Well, nothing's free. They have to hire people to do all these things."
The Chinook Observer office is a quick walk from the windswept Pacific coastline. Today, the paper's just come out and people are walking in to plunk down four quarters for a copy.
In back is editor and publisher Matt Winters. He's been here long enough to remember how it felt when his paper first went online in the late 1990s. All of a sudden the Observer's stories could be read in Australia or Russia.
"We, as everybody did in our industry, just loved the idea because we're all just inherently in the business — have this passionate desire to get information out to people and tell stories," he says.
'How Does This Compute?'
After a while, Winters says, some harsh economic realities became clear. Digital advertising is not lucrative, and print circulation has been falling.
"Out here in the hinterlands we were sort of looking at this model of gee, you know, we're giving away all this stuff we've agonized over the week to produce. How does this compute?" he says.
The answer is, it doesn't. So, the paper put up a paywall. In fact, more small papers have started charging than have large papers. That's according to research by Mike Jenner, a professor at the Missouri School of Journalism. He says it's partly because many small papers have a news monopoly — the Chinook Observer is the only one covering the Long Beach City Council. Still, Jenner says paywalls aren't magic.
"It's not going to replace the lost advertising revenue, but at this point these newspapers are looking for oxygen and this is a little flow of oxygen for them," he says.
As a reporter for the Observer, Amanda Frink has covered everything from a murder investigation to the annual cranberry harvest. She says she's glad the paper has a paywall now, but still: "I think eventually it's going to become the point where maybe there aren't newspapers anymore. So this whole paywall transition is necessary to keep jobs like mine," she says and laughs. "I certainly hope it does."
The Chinook Observer has been around since 1900. The paper's staff hopes it's taking the right steps to make sure the publication is still here at the close of this century.