Watching Foreign Movies Is Illegal In North Korea, But Some Do It Anyway

Jul 5, 2017
Originally published on July 5, 2017 12:44 pm

When Yeonmi Park was a young girl in North Korea's Ryanggang Province, near the Chinese border, she went to her uncle's house to watch TV. But this wasn't the usual state-run broadcast praising the "Dear Leader." The movie she watched at her uncle's house was illegal.

She covered the windows with blankets, turned the volume down low and huddled in close around the TV. She watched a pirated copy of Titanic.

"When I saw that movie for the first time, I was very confused," Park says. "I never heard my father telling my mother that he loved her. And my mother never told me she loved me, either. To me, love was only expressed [for] the Dear Leader. So, it was a very odd concept to me — how can a man die for a woman?"

By the time Park, now 23, escaped North Korea in 2007, she'd seen James Bond films, South Korean dramas — even American wrestling matches.

"Just for a couple of hours, you forget about how life is so hard," says Park, who now lives in the U.S. "Almost dreaming about a different planet."

Park's experience doesn't reflect the North Korea we think we know — and her story is not unique.

We see a country in isolation, but in today's society, even the most repressive regime can't keep everything out.

"The idea that North Korea is an information black hole is simply not true anymore," says James Pearson, a reporter for Reuters in South Korea and co-author of the 2015 book North Korea Confidential.

Pearson says illicit media undermines the Pyongyang regime because even Hollywood movies like Titanic can be subversive.

"That can start to change people's thinking," he says. "When you talk to defectors who've left the country, many of them say, 'It was looking at foreign media that started to help me question what it is that I hear from the government. Perhaps things aren't OK here.' "

According to a recent report by the Washington-based research group InterMedia, "media devices such as televisions and DVD players have reached near ubiquity in North Korea, with access and ownership a common phenomenon across nearly all demographic, socio-economic and political class divides." In Intermedia's survey of a group of 350 North Korean defectors, refugees and travelers, 92 percent said they watched foreign content on a DVD player.

"You can find anything but a cat's horn"

To understand how illicit media reaches such a closed-off society, you have to look to the mid-1990s. The fall of the Soviet Union crushed North Korea's fragile economy, and floods helped bring a devastating famine. The North Korean government failed to feed its people.

In that time of crisis, when North Koreans could no longer rely on the state, signs of grass-roots capitalism emerged, Pearson says. Makeshift stands popped up around the country, where people traded goods and food.

"During the famine, people said that the ones who turned to capitalism and trading were the ones that survived," Pearson says. "And that has been the real economy ever since. In a way, it's kind of North Korea's biggest open secret."

The black market has grown, he says, because government officials benefit from it. State salaries are so low that border guards can easily be bribed. Goods flow in from China — and these days, that includes more than food.

"There's a saying in North Korea," Pearson says. "'You can find anything but a cat's horn.' Meaning that if it exists, you can probably find it in the markets."

Charles, a North Korean defector now in the United States, used to peddle bootleg DVDs to make money — he says he risked his life doing it.

NPR contacted Charles — the Americanized version of his Korean first name — through the U.S. nonprofit Liberty in North Korea. We're withholding his last name to protect relatives he left behind.

"One of my friend's father was a police officer," he says. "At midnight, he'd go out to residences and crack down on foreign media."

Despite being a government official, he kept the confiscated DVDs for himself, so Charles always knew where to find the best movies. Without his friend's father ever knowing, Charles secretly copied the confiscated discs and redistributed them right back onto the market.

"I was a kid — I was 14 or 15 — so nobody would suspect me. I'd hide [DVDs] under my clothes, and some of them in my jackets, inside the pockets in the jackets," Charles says. "Everywhere."

Since Charles, now 22, left North Korea, it has become much easier to conceal foreign content. Traders and smugglers have turned to USB sticks and micro SD cards instead of DVDs.

"That's been a really popular way to spread information," says Pearson. "You can hide them between the pages of a book — you can swallow them, even, if you're caught with them."

Demand is so high that some Chinese companies manufacture products geared to the North Korean market. Pearson has reported on a device called the "notel," a portable media player with a USB input. Users plug two things in at once: the illicit media on a USB stick, and in case of inspection, a state-approved propaganda disc.

"Like, 'Kim Jong Il's Greatest Hits,' " Pearson says. "Should there be a knock on the door from the bowibu, which is the Gestapo, Stasi-esque institution in North Korea, you can just pull out the USB stick, open up the DVD drive and say, 'Look, I was watching this.' "

Change from within

Viewing and selling illicit media is still dangerous in North Korea. Under Kim Jong Un, defectors report stricter crackdowns by specialized government units that are much harder to bribe than their predecessors. But it doesn't seem to deter people from watching in secret.

"People crave to know what they don't know. People want to do what they're told not to do," says Jieun Baek, author of North Korea's Hidden Revolution.

She says this presents an opportunity for governments like the U.S. and South Korea to step in and take advantage of the demand for illegal foreign media.

"South Korea has both government- and independently funded programs that have been beaming information into North Korea for decades. Same with the U.S.," Baek says. "But all of this has to be ramped up substantially for there to be an effective counter-balance to North Korea's domestic propaganda machine."

She says it's a cost-effective way to lay the groundwork for long-term change. But it won't happen overnight.

"I think it's important to not over-romanticize the power of foreign information. 'Pyongyang Square' is not going to take place tomorrow because of a couple of USBs," Baek says. "But by flooding this country with foreign information, there will be dissenters in both thought and action who will emerge from within North Korean society."

Radio editor Arezou Rezvani contributed to this report.

Copyright 2017 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

MARY LOUISE KELLY, HOST:

When North Korea grabs the headlines, it's often because of something like this week's surprise missile test. Rarely do we hear about the lives of ordinary North Koreans.

RACHEL MARTIN, HOST:

We know the regime has walled itself off from the rest of the world, but our co-host David Greene learned that some North Koreans aren't as isolated as we might think.

DAVID GREENE, BYLINE: When Yeonmi Park was a young girl, she went to her uncle's house to watch a movie. This was not the state-run broadcast she was used to, praising the dear leader. No, this movie was illegal.

YEONMI PARK: What we do is we cover windows with blankets, And then we turn the volume really, really down so you have to be right next to TV.

GREENE: She was watching a pirated copy of "Titanic."

PARK: When I saw that movie first time, I was very confused. I never heard my father telling mother that he loved her. And my mother never told me she loved me, either. To me, like, love were the only words allowed to express to Dear Leader. So it was just very odd concept to me. How come a man can die for woman?

GREENE: By the time Yeonmi escaped North Korea in 2007, she'd also seen James Bond. She had seen South Korean dramas. She even watched American wrestling matches.

PARK: Yes. For a couple of hours, you just forget about how life so hard. I was dreaming about a different planet.

GREENE: Now, Yeonmi was getting all of this stuff through this network of smugglers and traders, a really active black market in her city. This is not the North Korea we know. We see the military parades. We see the goose-stepping soldiers, the tanks. We see the latest missile test. We see a hermit kingdom in isolation. But even in today's society, even the most repressive regime can't keep everything out.

JAMES PEARSON: The idea that North Korea is an information black hole is just simply not true anymore.

GREENE: That's James Pearson. He reports for Reuters in South Korea. And he also co-authored the book "North Korea Confidential." He says more and more North Koreans are getting their hands on illicit media. And don't think for a minute a movie like "Titanic" doesn't worry the North Korean regime. Just seeing visible tension, complicated emotions can make North Koreans feel deprived.

PEARSON: Things like that can start to change people's thinking. And when you talk to defectors who've left the country, many of them say, yeah, you know, I was looking at foreign media that started to help me question what it is that I hear from the government. You know, perhaps things are better off overseas, even in South Korea and even across the border in China.

GREENE: All right, so how is this forbidden content slipping into such a closed-off society? Well, let's step back for a minute to the mid-1990s. It looked like North Korea was going to collapse. There was devastating famine. The government failed to feed its people.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED BROADCAST)

TREVOR ROWE, BYLINE: Floods in North Korea left half a million people destitute and without food.

JULIE MCCARTHY, BYLINE: International relief agencies say 2 million children are at risk of starving to death.

GREENE: Now, here's the crazy thing. Capitalism helped save North Korea. These makeshift stands started popping up around the country selling goods, most importantly food.

PEARSON: During the famine, people said that the ones who turned to capitalism and trading were the ones that survived. And that North Korea, that real economy has essentially been the real economy ever since.

GREENE: Yet Pearson says this black market has grown because government officials are benefiting. State salaries are almost nothing, and so border guards can be easily bribed. Goods flow in from China. And these days, it's way more than just food.

What exactly is coming in?

PEARSON: Everything. There's a saying in North Korea that you can find anything but a cat's horn, meaning that if it exists, you can probably find it in the markets.

GREENE: Wow.

PEARSON: In a way, it's kind of North Korea's biggest open secret.

GREENE: And this young man was in on it.

CHARLES: Hi, David.

GREENE: Thank you for doing this with us.

CHARLES: Oh, no problem.

GREENE: Charles. He defected from North Korea when he was 17 years old. He swam across the Tumen River to China. And he now lives in the U.S. We are withholding his last name to protect the family he left behind. In North Korea's black market, Charles's role was peddling bootleg DVDs.

And how were you getting copies of these movies from the outside?

CHARLES: So one of my friend's father was a police officer.

GREENE: His friend's dad would confiscate foreign media, but then he'd keep those DVDs for himself. Charles would then secretly copy those confiscated DVDs and put them right back on the black market where they came from. How would you hide these DVDs when you were selling them?

CHARLES: Under the clothes and some of them in my jackets, inside of the pocket in the jackets.

GREENE: Everywhere?

CHARLES: Everywhere, yes.

GREENE: And if you got caught, you could be killed.

CHARLES: Yeah. It's very dangerous.

GREENE: They're risking their life because they are so desperate for content. James Pearson from Reuters says North Koreans are just getting more creative. They're using USB sticks and SD cards now instead of DVDs.

PEARSON: That's been a really popular way to spread information. You can hide them between pages of a book. You can swallow them even if you're caught with them.

GREENE: The demand right now is actually so high that some Chinese manufacturers have been creating special devices just for the North Korean market. One of them is called a Notel. It's this portable DVD player that has a USB input. Basically, it lets you put in two things at once - the thing you really want to watch and also the state-approved propaganda disk.

PEARSON: You can plug your USB stick full of illicit media in. You can open the DVD drive and put in some official state media like Kim Jong Il's greatest hits. And should there be a knock on the door from the bowibu, which is the kind of Gestapo, Stasi-esque institution in North Korea, you can just pull out the USB stick and then open the DVD drive and say look, I was watching this.

GREENE: Now, we can't be naive and think that all this has taught us a ton about North Korea. The reality is Kim Jong Un's regime is still in control. Just think of Charles, the defector we spoke to. He gamed the regime. He watched tons of foreign media, but he defected knowing he might never see his brother again.

Do you think you'll be able to talk to him at some point again soon?

CHARLES: I don't think so.

GREENE: That must be hard.

CHARLES: Yeah. Living here alone is kind of tough. And I still miss my brothers and my families. But, you know, I still strongly believe that they're going to open one day, you know. And I strongly believe, also, somebody is going to stand up and they're going to say something.

MARTIN: That was our co-host David Greene reporting. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.